The short answer
  • Choose Substack for simplicity, its reader network and the fastest path to charging.
  • Choose Beehiiv for growth tools, ad and sponsorship tooling, design control and an API.
  • Substack is free to publish and keeps a share of paid subscription revenue. Beehiiv charges for its plans and takes no cut of subscriptions.
  • Substack sends from a substack.com address. Beehiiv lets you send from your own domain on paid plans.
  • You can move in either direction later, but App Store subscribers and archive links need planning.

At a glance

Topic
Best forWriters who want to start fast and grow inside a reader networkPublishers running a newsletter as a growth and revenue business
How you payFree to publish; keeps a percentage of paid subscription revenue, plus Stripe's processing feesPaid plans by list size and features; no cut of subscription or digital product revenue
Growth toolsRecommendations, Notes, the Substack app, subscriber referrals and opt-in Boost offersReferral program, recommendations, paid recommendations and growth analytics
Ad monetizationA curated native sponsorship program for eligible publications; you can also sell your ownAd Network on paid plans, plus a direct sponsorship storefront on higher tiers
Design controlTheme editor for colors, fonts and layout; no custom CSS or HTMLWebsite builder and email templates; custom HTML blocks inside a fixed email structure
API and integrationsNo general-purpose public API for posts or subscribersAPI for posts, subscriptions, segments, custom fields, automations and webhooks (creating posts requires a higher-tier plan)
Sending domainSends from a substack.com address; you can change the sender name, not the addressYour own sending domain on paid plans, with DMARC required and automatic warm-up
PaymentsThrough your own connected Stripe account; iOS app purchases go through AppleThrough your own Stripe account, connected to the publication; ad earnings pay out through a beehiiv Wallet
Teams and titlesAdmin, contributor and byline roles; extra newsletters as sectionsAdmin, member and contributor roles; several publications per workspace, limits by plan
ExportingPosts, subscriber list and stats as a zip file, plus subscriber CSVsPosts (published, archived and drafts) and subscribers with custom fields as CSV

The real difference: platform versus business tool

Substack is a network as much as a tool. Readers discover writers inside it, and the experience is deliberately uniform. That is a strength when you are starting out and a constraint when you want to own the brand, the data and the sponsor relationships.

Beehiiv behaves more like business software. It gives you growth levers, ad revenue options, design control and an API, and expects you to use them. It suits publishers who think in terms of acquisition, revenue per reader and operations.

Who each one suits

Start with how the newsletter makes money and how far along it is. Features come second.

  • A new writer with no list. Both get you live in an afternoon. Substack adds a reader network and an app, which can matter more than any tool when nobody knows you yet.
  • A paid-first newsletter. Substack is the fastest way to start charging. Beehiiv suits you once the platform fee on a growing paid base outweighs the cost of a plan.
  • A sponsor-led newsletter. Beehiiv has more native tooling: an ad network for unsold slots and a storefront for direct deals. On Substack, most direct-sold sponsorships run outside the platform.
  • A B2B or data-driven newsletter. Custom fields, segments and an API matter here. Beehiiv has all three. Substack has segments and tags, but no general way to sync readers to a CRM.
  • A small team with several titles. Beehiiv runs several publications in one workspace. Substack handles extra newsletters as sections of one publication, or as separate publications.

How each platform makes money from you

Substack is free to publish at any list size. When you turn on paid subscriptions, it keeps a percentage of each subscription payment, and Stripe charges its own processing fees on top. A custom domain is a one-time paid unlock.

Beehiiv sells plans that rise with list size and features. It takes no cut of paid subscription or digital product revenue. You still pay Stripe's processing fees.

The two models cross over. A revenue share is cheap while paid revenue is small and grows with every new subscriber. A plan costs the same in a quiet month and a record one. Model both at the size you expect in two years, not today.

One more line item on Substack: subscriptions bought in the iOS app go through Apple, which takes its own fee. Substack lets you raise in-app prices to cover it or keep prices the same and absorb it.

Growth tools

Substack's growth engine is the network. Recommendations put your publication in front of readers who just subscribed to someone else. Notes and the app give readers a place to find you that is not their inbox. Subscriber referrals reward readers for bringing friends, and opt-in Boost lets Substack show discounts and trials on your behalf.

Beehiiv's growth tools are built for running acquisition on purpose. There is a referral program with rewards, free recommendations between newsletters and paid recommendations, where publishers pay to be recommended by others or earn by recommending. Reports show where subscribers came from and how each source engages.

The honest question is where your next thousand readers will come from. If the answer is other Substack writers, the network is hard to replace. If it is paid acquisition, partners and referrals, Beehiiv gives you more controls.

Monetization: subscriptions, ads, sponsorships and products

Paid subscriptions

Both platforms run paid tiers through Stripe. Substack adds founding member pricing and in-app purchase in its iOS app. Beehiiv requires a paid plan for paid subscriptions and supports several tiers, paywalls, offers and gift subscriptions.

Ads and sponsorships

Substack runs a curated native sponsorship program. Eligible publications, currently Bestsellers or those past a paid-subscriber threshold, can build a Creator Kit, which works as a media kit for brands Substack partners with. It is not an open marketplace. Anything else you sell yourself, and the booking, invoicing and reporting happen outside Substack.

Beehiiv has two layers. The Ad Network, on paid plans, offers CPM and CPC campaigns you can claim or skip, and it does not require exclusivity. Direct sponsorships, on higher tiers, add a storefront and proposals for selling your own placements. Beehiiv acts as merchant of record for those bookings, and they must be paid through Beehiiv rather than invoiced separately.

Products

Beehiiv sells digital products natively, with no cut beyond Stripe's fees. Substack is built around subscriptions, with podcasts, video and chat alongside the newsletter.

Ownership and data portability

Substack states that you own your content and your list. In practice you can export posts, the subscriber list and stats as a zip file, and subscriber CSVs with all columns. Readers who subscribe in the app still appear on your list with their email address.

Beehiiv exports every post, including drafts and archived posts, and subscribers in a quick or full version. The full version includes custom fields and statistics. A subscription export endpoint also exists in the API, but it has to be enabled for your publication.

The bigger ownership question is payments. Both connect to a Stripe account in your name. The difference shows up when you leave, which we cover below.

API and integrations

Substack has no general-purpose public API for managing posts or subscribers. Bestseller publications can also connect an AI assistant through Substack's MCP server to read their own stats. Anything else runs on exports and your own forms.

Beehiiv's API covers posts, post templates, subscriptions, segments, custom fields, tags, automations, polls, tiers and webhooks. Creating posts through the API requires a higher-tier plan, and generating API keys requires identity verification. Check the exact endpoints you need on the plan you will actually buy.

This is the row that decides how far you can automate. Drafting pipelines, CRM syncs and sponsor placements that flow into the issue all need an API.

Design, deliverability and analytics

Substack's theme editor changes colors, fonts and layouts. There is no custom CSS or HTML in the editor. That keeps every issue readable and every publication recognizably Substack.

Beehiiv offers a website builder and templated emails. You can add custom HTML blocks and CSS, but the email head and compliance footer are fixed, and fully custom HTML email is not supported.

Deliverability control is the sharpest difference. Every Substack email goes out from an address at substack.com. You can change the sender name, not the address. On Beehiiv's paid plans you send from your own domain, DMARC is required and new domains warm up automatically. A dedicated IP is an Enterprise option.

For analytics, Substack shows subscribers, revenue and post performance, and you can connect Google Analytics or Tag Manager. Beehiiv reports on posts, clicks, subscriber sources and engagement over time.

Teams and multiple titles

Substack teams have admins, contributors and byline-only authors. Contributors can edit and publish drafts but cannot see settings or stats. Extra newsletters live as sections of one publication, which subscribers can opt in or out of.

Beehiiv organizes everything in a workspace with admins, members and contributors. Contributors can draft but cannot publish. Access can be set per publication, and the number of seats and publications depends on your plan.

Moving between them

Moves in both directions are common, and each platform documents the path in.

Substack to Beehiiv

Beehiiv imports free posts from your Substack URL and paid posts from the Substack export file. Video posts, podcast posts, comments, galleries and categories do not come across, and paywall positions reset. Free subscribers import from CSV with mapped fields.

Paid subscribers move by copying customer and card data from your Substack-connected Stripe account into the one connected to Beehiiv, then recreating subscriptions at their existing prices. You then pause billing on Substack so nobody is charged twice. Comped, gifted and iOS subscribers are not in Stripe, so they need complimentary access and a note asking App Store subscribers to cancel with Apple. Because both use the same post URL pattern, a custom domain can carry over without redirect rules.

Beehiiv to Substack

Substack imports Beehiiv posts from your URL and an export file. According to Substack, Beehiiv's export includes free posts and only previews of paid ones, so paid archives need extra work. Subscribers import as free. Substack's general guide for paid members from other platforms is to comp them and then move them onto Substack billing, so plan the messaging carefully.

Our migration guide walks through the cutover step by step.

Choose Substack or Beehiiv

Choose Substack if

  • You are starting out and want to write, not configure
  • Paid subscriptions are your main revenue
  • The Substack network and app matter to your growth
  • A shared substack.com sending address is fine for you

Choose Beehiiv if

  • Sponsorships and ads are a big part of revenue
  • You want referral programs and growth analytics
  • You plan to automate or integrate with other tools
  • You want to send from your own domain

A worked example

This publisher is fictional. It shows how the questions above play out, not a real result.

A two-person team runs a weekly newsletter on regional real estate. It has a free list, a small paid tier for deeper market data and a few sponsors from local brokers. Growth comes mostly from readers forwarding the issue.

On Substack, they would launch in a day and charge from week one. Their audience is local, though, so the national reader network is less of an advantage. Sponsors would be sold, invoiced and reported outside the platform.

On Beehiiv, they would pay for a plan from the start. In return they get a referral program to reward forwards, a sponsor storefront for brokers, their own sending domain and an API to pull listing data into each issue.

The deciding factor is the sponsor line. If sponsors are a side income, Substack's simplicity wins. If sponsors pay the bills, the tooling on Beehiiv, or a system built around either platform, matters more than the fee model.

What most comparisons miss

The revenue share compounds as you grow

A percentage of paid revenue feels small at the start and large at scale. Model it at the subscriber count you expect in two years, not the one you have today.

App Store subscribers do not move with Stripe

Readers who pay through Substack's iOS app are billed by Apple, and Apple does not transfer billing between platforms. Count them before you plan a move.

Your sending reputation lives where your domain lives

On Substack the sending address belongs to Substack. On Beehiiv's paid plans it can be yours, and that reputation moves with you to the next platform.

Sponsorships do not depend on the platform

Direct-sold sponsorships can run on either platform. What matters is the outreach, booking and reporting system around the send. Note that Beehiiv's direct sponsorship bookings must be paid through Beehiiv.

API access decides how far you can automate

If you want AI-assisted drafts, data syncs or custom tools, the API matters more than any single feature. Check which endpoints your plan includes.

How we help

We build the systems around newsletter platforms: production pipelines, sponsor operations and data syncs. We have built on Beehiiv's API and moved a B2B newsletter off Beehiiv onto its own infrastructure. For the wider field, read how to choose a newsletter platform, or see how we run platform migrations.

Not sure which way to go? Start with a process audit and get an honest recommendation, even if it is to stay put.

Platforms change their features and pricing often. Facts here were checked against each platform's help center and documentation in October 2026. Check each platform's current plans before you decide.