The short answer
  • Choose Substack if the writing is the product and you want to publish and charge with almost no setup.
  • Choose Kit if email is how you sell, and sequences, tags and products drive the business.
  • Substack takes a share of paid subscription revenue. Kit charges a plan by subscriber count, plus a per-sale Commerce fee that includes card processing.
  • Kit has a full API on every plan, including free. Substack has no general-purpose public API.
  • Substack uses your own Stripe account. Kit Commerce uses a separate, Kit-managed one. That decides how paying readers move later.

At a glance

Topic
Best forWriters who want simplicity and a reader networkCreators building a business around products and automations
How you payFree to publish; a percentage of paid subscription revenue, plus Stripe processingPlans by subscriber count, with a free tier; a per-sale Commerce fee that includes card processing
AutomationsWelcome emails for free, paid, imported and founding readers, plus Boost and referral emails; little beyond thatVisual automations and sequences on paid plans; none on the free plan
Selling productsPaid subscriptionsDigital products and paid newsletters through Kit Commerce
Ads and sponsorshipsYour own sponsors are allowed; a curated native sponsorship program for Bestsellers and publications past a paid-subscriber thresholdNewsletter Sponsorships paid per verified click; programmatic Kit Ads closed to new applicants at review
DiscoverySubstack network, Notes and appCreator Network recommendations
PaymentsYour own connected Stripe accountA separate Kit-managed Stripe account
Sending addressPosts send from a substack.com address you cannot changeYour own domain, with a verified sending domain (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) recommended
API and integrationsNo general-purpose public API (only limited official access)Full API on every plan; most app integrations on paid plans
DesignUniform Substack look; custom domain for a one-time feeEmail templates, landing pages and a newsletter site on your own domain
Teams and titlesAdmins and contributors; several publications per account, each with its own Stripe accountSeats by plan; one subscriber list per account

The real difference

Substack is a publication with a built-in audience. Kit is marketing software for creators. If your work is the writing, Substack keeps it simple. If your work is a business that uses email to sell, Kit gives you the levers.

Everything below follows from that. Substack decides most things for you, so you can write. Kit hands you the controls, so you can build.

Who each one suits

By business model

If paid subscriptions are the business, Substack is the shortest path from idea to checkout. Kit can run a paid newsletter too, but its strength is everything around the subscription.

If you sell courses, templates or downloads, Kit fits the shape of the work. A tag records what each reader bought or downloaded. A sequence offers the next thing at the right moment.

If sponsors pay the bills, neither platform runs direct-sold ad operations for you. Substack lets you host sponsored content and runs a curated program for its top publications. Kit runs a sponsorship marketplace inside the app. Your own outreach, contracts and reporting sit outside both.

By stage

Starting from zero, Substack's network and app can bring you first readers you would not reach alone. Kit's free plan covers a list of up to 10,000 subscribers, without automations or sequences.

Once established, the question shifts to margin and tooling. That is where the next section matters.

How each one makes money from you

Substack is free to publish. When you turn on paid subscriptions, it keeps a percentage of each subscription payment, and Stripe charges its own processing fees on top.

Two details change the math. Subscriptions bought through Substack's iOS app carry Apple's fee as well. And from December 1, 2026, Substack calculates, collects and remits sales tax or VAT on paid subscriptions for you.

Kit bills a monthly or annual plan, priced by subscriber tier. Its help center says it bills on confirmed subscribers, moves you up a tier automatically, and leaves moving down to you.

Kit Commerce is available on every plan, including free. There is no monthly fee for it. You pay a fee on each sale, and card processing is included.

The models scale differently. A revenue share grows with what readers pay you. A plan grows with how many people are on your list. A large free list with a small paid tier and a small list with a high price land in very different places. Model both at the size you expect in two years.

Growth tools

Substack's growth runs through its network. Recommendations let you promote other publications, and their writers are prompted to recommend you back. Readers who follow you in the app see your Notes in their feed.

Substack also offers title testing for publications with at least 200 subscribers. Some SEO features, such as sitemaps and Search Console verification, unlock as a publication grows.

Kit's growth runs through its Creator Network. You can recommend up to 20 creators, and up to five appear on your forms and landing pages. Paid Recommendations let you earn from the creators you recommend, and the pricing page lists them on the Creator and Pro plans.

Kit also has unlimited forms and landing pages on every plan, attribution data on what grows your list, and a referral program run through SparkLoop on the Pro plan.

Monetization

On Substack

Paid subscriptions come in monthly, annual and founding member tiers. Substack Boost can show automatic discounts to engaged free readers. You can switch it off if you would rather not discount.

Substack's help center says publishers are welcome to host sponsored content, within its Publisher Agreement and content guidelines. Its native sponsorship program is curated. Bestseller publications, or those with at least 100 paid subscribers, can publish a Creator Kit, and Substack's team may reach out with a brand match.

On Kit

Kit Commerce sells digital products and paid newsletters, with discounts and pay-what-you-want pricing. Paid newsletters go out as broadcasts filtered to people who bought the subscription product.

Newsletter Sponsorships are pre-approved campaigns that pay per unique verified click. Only paid plan users can express interest in them. Kit Ads, its programmatic option, was not accepting new applications at the time of review. Kit keeps a share of sponsorship revenue.

On both platforms, the built-in programs are a supplement. If direct-sold sponsorships are a real revenue line, the outreach, booking and reporting system is yours to build.

Ownership and data portability

Substack's export is a single ZIP from Settings, Exports. It holds your subscriber list and your posts. Every publication also has a public RSS feed at /feed.

Kit exports subscribers as a CSV with first name, email, signup date, status, tags, location, attribution data and custom fields. That is a rich export, and it is worth running regularly.

Payments are where the platforms differ most. Substack connects to your own Stripe account, so your customer records sit in an account you control. Kit Commerce requires a separate Kit-managed Stripe Express account, even if you already have Stripe.

Neither choice is wrong. But it decides how easily paying readers can follow you to another platform.

API and integrations

Substack has no general-purpose public API for posts or subscribers. Admins of Bestseller publications can also connect an AI assistant that reads publication data, such as subscriber counts and post performance.

In practice, Substack integrations rely on exports, RSS and your own signup forms.

Kit's v4 API covers subscribers, tags, sequences, broadcasts, forms, custom fields, segments, purchases and webhooks, with API keys or OAuth. At the time of review, API access is available on every plan, including free. Some older third-party integrations still ask for a legacy v3 key.

Design and site control

Substack gives every publication the same clean, recognizable layout, on the web and in the inbox. That consistency is part of what makes its network feel like one place. A custom domain costs a one-time fee, and Substack recommends a subdomain such as www.

Kit gives you a visual email template editor, landing pages and a newsletter site that shows your published broadcasts. All of it can run on your own domain.

Deliverability control

Substack sends every post from a [subdomain]@substack.com address, and its help center says you cannot change it. Replies forward to you. The upside is no DNS work. The trade-off is that your sending reputation sits inside Substack's.

Substack also screens imported lists. If readers did not opt in, it may restrict the publication.

Kit says to send from a domain you own and strongly recommends a verified sending domain with SPF, DKIM and DMARC records. That is more setup, and it builds a reputation that belongs to you. The Pro plan adds deliverability reporting.

Analytics

Substack's dashboard shows total and paid subscribers, gross annualized revenue, open rates and views. Reads in the Substack app count as opens, so its numbers are not directly comparable with an ordinary email platform's.

Kit reports on broadcasts, sequences and automations. Pro adds engagement analytics, subscriber engagement scoring and Subscriber Signals.

Teams and multiple titles

Substack separates admins, who have full access to settings, from contributors, who can edit and publish drafts. One account can run several publications, but each needs its own Stripe account. Sections let one publication send separate newsletters to subsets of readers.

Kit's pricing page lists one user on the free plan, two on Creator and unlimited on Pro. Kit keeps one subscriber list per account. Its own advice is to use separate accounts for businesses with distinct audiences.

Moving between them

From Substack to Kit

  • Export subscribers from Substack and import them into Kit. Kit suggests a tag for paid subscribers so you can find them later.
  • Kit's guide says there is no convenient way to move paid subscriptions with their payment details. Its recommended path is to cancel on Substack and ask paying readers to subscribe again in Kit.
  • Do not click Disconnect Stripe on Substack to do that. Substack says it refunds and cancels all paid subscriptions and notifies paying readers. Ask Substack support first.
  • Rebuild the archive by recreating posts as broadcasts, publishing them to your Kit newsletter site and setting their original dates.
  • Pause automations before importing. Adding imported subscribers to tags or forms can trigger them.

From Kit to Substack

  • Upload your subscriber CSV. Substack checks imports for readers who did not opt in.
  • Import posts through Substack's importer, which accepts RSS feeds, including Kit's. Some feeds only include recent posts, so check what arrives.
  • Paid readers are harder. Kit Commerce runs on a Kit-managed Stripe account. Substack's guidance for paid members from other platforms is to comp them, then move them onto Substack billing. Plan for readers to re-enter card details.
  • Sequences and automations have no equivalent beyond Substack's welcome emails and a few built-in automated emails. Decide what to drop.
  • Sending moves from your own domain to a substack.com address.

Our migration guide covers the full sequence, and platform migrations shows how we run them.

Choose Substack if

  • The writing is the product
  • Paid subscriptions are the core offer
  • You want discovery inside a reader network
  • You would rather not manage DNS or sending
  • You want paying readers in your own Stripe account

Choose Kit if

  • You sell more than subscriptions
  • Sequences and tags drive your revenue
  • You want to send from your own domain
  • You need an API and integrations
  • You want site and email design control

A worked example

This publisher is fictional. The example shows how the questions play out, not real results.

A baker writes a weekly newsletter with a small paid tier. She also sells a recipe e-book and plans a seasonal online course. Most new readers find her through other writers.

On Substack, the paid tier is easy and the network keeps feeding her growth. The e-book and course would live on another tool, so a buyer and a subscriber become two records in two places.

On Kit, one record holds the subscription, the e-book purchase and a course waitlist tag. A sequence can offer the course to e-book buyers only. She gives up Substack's network and takes on domain setup.

The deciding question is where next year's revenue comes from. If it is mostly subscriptions, Substack is simpler. If products grow, Kit's single view of the reader pays off.

What most comparisons miss

Whose Stripe account it is

Substack connects your own Stripe account. Kit Commerce runs on a separate Kit-managed one. That one detail decides whether paying readers can move without re-entering cards.

The From address is fixed on Substack

Substack posts always send from a substack.com address. If your brand, or a B2B audience's mail filters, depend on your own domain, weigh that early.

App purchases and tax change the margin

Apple's fee applies to Substack subscriptions bought in its iOS app, and Substack-managed sales tax starts on December 1, 2026. Compare what you actually take home, not the headline rate.

Automation is a long-term asset

Sequences and segments built well keep working for years. If your business depends on them, that capability matters more than launch simplicity.

You can combine them

Some creators publish on Substack and use other tools for products and funnels. The cost is reader data split across systems, and someone has to reconcile it.

How we help

We build the pieces neither platform covers: sponsor operations, reader data sync and production tooling. We also plan moves in either direction, with paid readers and archives handled carefully. See our Substack and Kit pages, or start with a process audit.

Platforms change their features and pricing often. Check each platform's current plans before you decide.