- Choose Beehiiv for built-in growth tools, an ad network and a fast start.
- Choose Ghost for open-source software you own, a full website and memberships.
- Neither takes a cut of subscription revenue. Beehiiv charges by plan and subscriber count. Ghost(Pro) charges by plan and member count, or you self-host.
- Both have APIs. Check which endpoints sit on which plan before you build.
At a glance
| Topic | ||
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Publishers focused on growth and ad monetization | Publishers who want to own their site, members and data |
| How you pay | Free plan, then paid plans by subscriber count and features; no cut of paid subscriptions or digital products | Ghost(Pro) hosting plans by member count, or self-host; paid memberships from the Publisher plan up; no Ghost transaction fee |
| Growth tools | Referrals, recommendations, paid recommendations and growth analytics | Recommendations and social web (ActivityPub) following, in beta; fewer built-in growth levers |
| Ad monetization | Ad network on paid plans, plus direct sponsorships | No built-in ad network, though third-party networks can be added; direct sponsorships sold and placed by you |
| Paid subscriptions | On paid plans, through a Stripe account you own | Memberships and tiers through your own Stripe account |
| Ownership | Hosted platform; subscribers and posts export as CSV | Open source; self-host or managed |
| Design | Website builder and email templates; branding removal on higher tiers | Full theme control for the site; newsletter design through per-newsletter settings |
| API and integrations | API on every plan; creating posts needs a higher tier, webhooks a paid plan | Admin API (read and write) and read-only Content API, plus webhooks; custom integrations from the Publisher plan up on Ghost(Pro) |
| Email delivery | Handled by Beehiiv; dedicated IPs on Enterprise | Included on Ghost(Pro); self-hosted sites need Mailgun for bulk email |
| Analytics | Built-in newsletter and growth analytics; advanced analytics on higher tiers | Native web, newsletter and member analytics since Ghost 6; self-hosted needs a Tinybird account |
| Multiple titles | Several publications per account on paid plans | Several newsletters per site, by plan |
| Effort | Low | Moderate, higher if self-hosted |
The real difference
Beehiiv gives you a growth engine out of the box: referrals, recommendations, paid recommendations and an ad network, all tuned for newsletters. Ghost gives you a publishing platform you own, with a full website, themes and memberships, and leaves growth tactics more to you.
Who each one suits
Start with how the newsletter earns. Then look at where it is in its life.
Beehiiv suits a newsletter that is the product. Ads, sponsorships and subscriber growth are the levers, and the team wants them in one place without hiring a developer. Plans scale with subscribers, so it works at launch and keeps working as the list grows.
Ghost suits a publisher that thinks like a publication. The website matters as much as the inbox. Memberships, tiers and a searchable archive on your own domain are the core, and owning the software is part of the point.
By stage, the split is usually this. A solo writer who wants to grow fast tends to start on Beehiiv. A writer with an audience and a paid model in mind often prefers Ghost. A small media company can run on either. The choice comes down to whether it wants growth tools bundled or a stack it controls.
How each one makes money from you
Neither platform takes a cut of your subscription revenue. That is the most important line on both pricing pages.
Beehiiv sells plans. There is a free plan, then paid tiers that rise with subscriber count and unlock features such as paid subscriptions, the ad network and automations. Beehiiv says it takes nothing from paid subscription or digital product revenue. Stripe's processing fee still applies.
Ghost sells hosting. Ghost(Pro) plans rise with the number of members, and paid memberships, custom themes and custom integrations start on the Publisher plan. Ghost adds no transaction fee. Or you self-host the open-source software and pay for your own server and email sending instead.
So the question is not who is cheaper today. It is which features you need, at the list size you expect in two years, on each platform's current plan page.
Growth tools
This is Beehiiv's home ground. A referral program, recommendations between newsletters and paid recommendations are all built in. You can switch them on in an afternoon.
Ghost has recommendations too. Since Ghost 6, a site can also join the social web through ActivityPub, a feature Ghost still labels beta. People on Mastodon can follow and reply to your posts, and Ghost says Threads and Flipboard mostly work. It needs a custom domain and runs on Ghost(Pro) and self-hosted sites alike.
Beyond that, growth on Ghost is mostly your job. Search traffic to your own domain, a referral tool you add and paid acquisition you run.
Monetization
Ads and sponsorships
Beehiiv runs an ad network on its paid plans. It sources advertisers, handles payment and pays out monthly. You decide which offers to run. It also supports direct sponsorships. Earnings land in a beehiiv Wallet linked to a Stripe Express account Beehiiv sets up for each publication.
Ghost has no built-in ad network. From the Publisher plan up you can add a third-party one, and direct sponsorships are yours to sell, place in the post and report on. Some publishers prefer that: no network rates anchoring the conversation, and full control of the slot.
Paid subscriptions
Both run paid subscriptions through Stripe. Beehiiv connects a Stripe account you own for paid subscriptions and digital products. Ghost connects your own Stripe account and builds members, tiers and offers around it.
Ghost's membership model runs through the whole site: content can be public, for members or for specific paid tiers. Beehiiv's paid tiers are built around the newsletter and its premium content.
Products
Beehiiv sells digital products natively and takes no cut. Ghost is built around memberships rather than a product store, so publishers selling one-off products usually pair it with a separate checkout.
Ownership and data portability
Ghost is open source. If you leave Ghost(Pro), the same software runs on your own server. That is ownership in the literal sense.
Beehiiv is hosted, but it is not locked. Subscribers export as CSV in a quick or full version, and the full version adds custom fields and stats. Posts export too, including drafts and archived posts. Download links expire after 24 hours, so save the file when it lands.
The detail that decides real portability is payments. On both platforms, paying members are Stripe customers. Moving them means moving Stripe customer data, not just a CSV. The migration sections below cover how.
API and integrations
Ghost's Admin API can do what the admin screen does. It creates and edits posts, members, tiers, offers and newsletters, and it can publish a post as an email to a chosen segment of members. The Content API is read-only, for pulling posts into other sites and apps. On Ghost(Pro), custom integrations and webhooks start on the Publisher plan.
Beehiiv has an API on every plan for subscriptions, posts, automations and more. Two parts are gated at the time of review. Creating posts through the API sits on a higher tier, and webhooks need a paid plan. Beehiiv's own pages do not always agree on the exact tier, so confirm it in the developer docs and on the current plan page.
If your plan is to automate drafts from a production pipeline, that gating matters more than any feature list.
Design and site control
Ghost gives you full control of the website. Themes are written in Handlebars, and a developer can build any layout, section or sponsor slot you need.
Ghost's email design is more fixed. Each newsletter has settings for header image, title and body fonts, feature image and footer, rather than a template you code. Publishers who want a heavily designed email feel that constraint.
Beehiiv gives you a website builder and an email editor with templates. Removing Beehiiv branding is a higher-tier feature. It is quicker to make something clean. It is harder to make something unusual.
Deliverability control
On Beehiiv and on Ghost(Pro), email delivery is handled for you. That is a real benefit: infrastructure run by people who do it all day. Beehiiv offers dedicated IPs on its Enterprise plan.
Self-hosted Ghost is different. Ghost's docs say bulk newsletters cannot go over basic SMTP and that Mailgun is the only supported bulk email provider. You set up the account and the DNS, and you own the sending reputation.
Whichever you pick, send from your own domain with SPF, DKIM and DMARC in place before your first issue.
Analytics
Beehiiv's analytics are built around the newsletter and its growth, with advanced analytics on higher tiers.
Ghost 6 added native analytics covering web traffic, newsletters and members in one place. On Ghost(Pro) they are included from the Publisher plan up. Self-hosted sites need a free Tinybird account and their own API key.
Neither will tell you which sponsor renewed because of which report. That data lives in your sales tools, which is why sponsor reporting is usually built outside both.
Teams and multiple titles
Beehiiv plans add team seats and publications as you move up, so a small media company can run several titles from one account.
Ghost handles it differently. One site can carry several newsletters, and members choose which to receive. Staff users and the number of newsletters both rise with the Ghost(Pro) plan. Titles that need separate brands and websites usually mean separate Ghost sites.
Moving from Beehiiv to Ghost
Ghost has a Beehiiv migrator in Ghost Admin under Settings, Advanced, Import/Export. It imports posts and subscribers. For developers, Ghost's migration CLI also converts a Beehiiv post export into a file Ghost can import.
Free subscribers move cleanly. Paid ones take more care. Ghost's docs note that the Stripe account tied to a Beehiiv site cannot be connected to another platform, so paying members move by migrating Stripe customer data to the account Ghost uses. Ghost(Pro) customers can ask Ghost's migrations team for help.
Then the usual work. Redirect old archive URLs, check that sponsor placements and embeds survived, and warm up sending on the new platform.
Moving from Ghost to Beehiiv
Beehiiv's Content Import pulls posts from Ghost through the Ghost API. Paywalled posts need to be made public for the import, then paywalled again in Beehiiv.
Beehiiv's own docs list what does not come across: comments, code blocks and paywall placement. Internal links can break because Beehiiv post URLs include /p/, so plan redirects.
Free members export as CSV from Ghost's Members screen. Paid members move by transferring Stripe customer data and mapping Ghost tiers to Beehiiv tiers. Pause subscriptions in Ghost first, or readers get billed twice.
Our migration guide covers the full sequence, and platform migrations explains how we run one.
Choose Beehiiv or Ghost
Choose Beehiiv if
- The newsletter is the product and growth is the priority
- You want an ad network to fill weeks without a sponsor
- You want to launch without a developer
- You plan several titles under one account
- Managed email delivery suits you
Choose Ghost if
- The website and archive matter as much as the inbox
- You want open-source software you can host yourself
- Memberships and tiers are the core model
- You have, or can hire, developer time for themes and integrations
- You want content, members and analytics in software you control
A worked example
This publisher is fictional. The example shows how the trade-offs play out, not a real result.
A two-person team runs a weekly newsletter on urban planning. Revenue today comes from a handful of direct sponsors. They want to add a paid tier for long-form analysis next year, and their archive already brings in steady search traffic.
On Beehiiv, they get referrals and recommendations to grow faster, and the ad network can fill weeks without a direct sponsor. The paid tier sits on a plan they upgrade to, with no cut taken.
On Ghost, the archive becomes a proper publication site on their own domain, with tiers gating the long-form pieces. Sponsors are placed by hand or through a tool they add. Growth leans on search and the social web more than on built-in referrals.
The deciding question for them is the archive. If search is a major source of new readers, Ghost's site control weighs more. If most growth will come from other newsletters, Beehiiv's network tools weigh more. Either way, they test both exports in week one.
What most comparisons miss
Growth tools can be rebuilt; ownership is harder to add later
You can add referral programs and growth tooling around Ghost. Adding true ownership to a hosted platform is not possible, so decide which matters more long term.
Ad networks are a floor, not a ceiling
A built-in ad network fills unsold slots, but direct-sold sponsorships usually pay more. Either platform can support direct sales with the right system.
Self-hosting changes the cost math
Self-hosted Ghost can be inexpensive, but count the time spent on updates, backups, Mailgun and analytics setup.
No cut does not mean the same cost
Both take nothing from subscriptions. One bills by subscribers, the other by members, and free readers count toward both. A large free list with a small paid tier can cost more than expected. Model the plan at your total audience, not your paying one.
The API you need may be one tier up
Automating drafts on Beehiiv needs post creation, which sits on higher tiers. On Ghost(Pro), custom integrations start on the Publisher plan. Price the plan you will build on, not the plan you start on.
How we help
We build on both. Our own work includes AI drafting pipelines that create Beehiiv drafts through its API, and moving a B2B trade newsletter off Beehiiv onto its own sending stack. On Ghost we work through the Admin API, webhooks and theme layer inside your own instance. See how we work with Ghost, or start with a process audit if you are weighing a move.
Platforms change their features and pricing often. Check each platform's current plans before you decide.