- Choose Substack if you want to start writing today with nothing to set up.
- Choose Ghost if you want full ownership, your own site and design, and no revenue share.
- Substack keeps a percentage of paid revenue. Ghost charges for hosting, or nothing if you self-host, and takes no transaction fee.
- Both use your own Stripe account, so paid members can move between them.
- Ghost asks more of you, especially if you self-host.
At a glance
| Topic | ||
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Writers who want simplicity and a reader network | Publishers who want ownership, a full website and flexibility |
| How you pay | Free to publish; keeps a percentage of paid subscription revenue, plus Stripe's processing fees | Ghost(Pro) plans by audience size and staff, or self-host; no transaction fees (paid memberships from the Publisher plan up) |
| Ownership | Hosted on Substack, with its branding and network | Open source; your site, members and data, on your terms |
| Design | Theme editor for colors, fonts and layout; no custom CSS or HTML | Custom site themes from the Publisher plan up or self-hosted; newsletter design through settings |
| Memberships and payments | Paid subscriptions through your own connected Stripe account; iOS app purchases go through Apple | Memberships and tiers through your own Stripe account |
| API and integrations | No general-purpose public API (only limited official access) | Admin and Content APIs plus webhooks (custom integrations from the Publisher plan up) |
| Discovery | Built-in reader network and app | Recommendations, the Ghost Explore directory and social web (ActivityPub) following, in beta; no large in-house reader network |
| Email sending | Sends from a substack.com address you cannot change | Ghost(Pro) manages delivery; self-hosted sites need Mailgun for newsletters |
| Analytics | Built-in stats; connect Google Analytics or Tag Manager | Native, cookie-free web, email and member analytics (advanced analytics from the Publisher plan up) |
| Teams and newsletters | Admin, contributor and byline roles; extra newsletters as sections | Administrator, editor, author and contributor roles; several newsletters per site, limits by plan |
| Exporting | Posts, subscriber list and stats as a zip file | Content as JSON, members as CSV, theme files and post analytics |
| Effort | Very low | Moderate, higher if self-hosted |
The real difference: rent or own
Substack is like renting a well-run apartment in a busy building: easy to move in, with neighbors who might find you, but you live by the building's rules. Ghost is like owning a house: more to look after, but you decide how it looks, who you share data with and what it costs.
Neither is the better deal in general. Renting is cheaper when you are small and unsure. Owning pays off once the business is real and the building's rules start to cost you.
Who each one suits
- A writer testing an idea. Substack. Nothing to configure, and the network may bring readers before you have any.
- A paid newsletter with a growing base. Ghost becomes more attractive as revenue grows, because it takes no transaction fee. Substack stays attractive if most growth comes from its network.
- A publication that is also a website. Ghost. It is a full publishing system with pages, tags, custom themes and search-friendly URLs on your own domain.
- A team with editors and freelancers. Ghost's four staff roles map well to a newsroom. Substack's roles are simpler: admin, contributor and byline.
- A publisher who wants to automate. Ghost, from the Publisher plan up or self-hosted. Its Admin API can create drafts and manage members. Substack has no general API for that.
How each platform makes money from you
Substack is free to publish. When you turn on paid subscriptions, it keeps a percentage of each payment, and Stripe charges its processing fees on top. A custom domain is a one-time paid unlock.
Ghost(Pro) charges a hosting plan priced by audience size and staff seats. It takes no transaction fees; you pay Stripe's processing fees and keep the rest. Paid memberships, custom themes and custom integrations start on the Publisher plan, not the entry Starter plan.
Self-hosted Ghost is free software. You pay for a server, email delivery through Mailgun and the time it takes to run them.
The models cross over. A revenue share costs little while paid revenue is small and grows with every subscriber. Hosting costs track audience size, not revenue. Model both at the size you expect in two years.
Growth and discovery
Substack's strongest feature is the network. Recommendations put you in front of readers who just subscribed elsewhere. Notes and the app give readers a feed that is not their inbox. Subscriber referrals and opt-in Boost offers add to it.
Ghost has recommendations too, shown when a new member signs up. Ghost Explore is a directory of Ghost publications. The social web feature, in beta, lets people on open platforms follow, like and reply to your posts from their own accounts.
What Ghost does not have is a large in-house audience. Growth on Ghost comes from search, social, partners and your own marketing. A Ghost site does give you strong footing for search, because the archive lives on your domain.
Monetization
Both platforms are built for paid subscriptions, and both run them through your own Stripe account. Ghost supports several paid tiers, each with monthly and yearly prices and an optional free trial. Substack adds founding member pricing and in-app purchase through its iOS app, where Apple bills the reader.
For sponsorships, Substack runs a curated native program. Eligible publications, currently Bestsellers or those past a paid-subscriber threshold, can build a Creator Kit for brands Substack partners with. It is not an open marketplace.
Ghost had no built-in ad network or sponsorship marketplace at the time of review. Third-party ad networks can be added from the Publisher plan up, and sponsors are sold directly and placed in the post or theme. That is more work, and also more control over placements, pricing and reporting.
Ownership and data portability
Substack states that you own your content and your list. You can export posts, the subscriber list and stats as a zip file at any time.
Ghost goes further, because it is open source and the export format is documented. Content and settings export as JSON. Members export as CSV, including each member's Stripe customer ID. You can also download your theme files and post analytics.
On Ghost you also own the URL structure, the theme and, if you self-host, the server. Nobody else decides how your archive looks or where it lives.
API and integrations
Substack has no general-purpose public API for posts or subscribers. Bestseller publications can connect an AI assistant to read their own stats. Everything else runs on exports and your own forms.
Ghost has a Content API for reading published content and an Admin API for creating posts, managing members and more, plus webhooks. It also connects to Zapier, Make and n8n. On Ghost(Pro), custom integrations and the Admin API start on the Publisher plan. Self-hosted sites have them by default.
Design, email and analytics
Substack's theme editor changes colors, fonts and layouts, with no custom CSS or HTML. Every publication stays readable and recognizably Substack.
Ghost sites run on themes you can buy, adapt or build from scratch, from the Publisher plan up. The Starter plan uses Ghost's default theme with layout and color settings. Newsletter emails use Ghost's own template, styled through design settings rather than the theme.
Every Substack email goes out from a substack.com address. On Ghost(Pro), Ghost manages delivery, authentication and monitoring for you. On self-hosted Ghost, bulk email requires a Mailgun account, and deliverability becomes your job.
Substack shows subscribers, revenue and post performance, and connects to Google Analytics or Tag Manager. Ghost's native analytics cover web traffic, newsletters and audience growth, with cookie-free, first-party traffic data.
Teams and multiple newsletters
Substack teams have admins, contributors and byline-only authors. Extra newsletters live as sections of one publication, and readers choose which ones they get.
Ghost has administrators, editors, authors and contributors. Contributors can write drafts but not publish, and they do not count toward plan staff limits. One site can send several newsletters, with the number set by your plan.
Moving between them
Substack to Ghost
Ghost has a built-in Substack migrator. You give it your Substack URL, upload the Substack export, then upload your free and paid subscriber CSVs. Ghost imports posts and members in one pass.
For paid members, connect Ghost to the same Stripe account Substack uses. Ghost's guide notes that Substack's fee can keep applying to existing subscriptions after the move until it is removed, and Ghost offers help with that. Update the Stripe statement descriptor too, since it may still name Substack.
If you used a custom domain on Substack, add redirects in Ghost. Substack uses /p/ in post URLs, and Ghost uses /p/ for previews, so the redirect rule needs care. Readers who pay through Substack's iOS app are billed by Apple, and Apple does not transfer billing between platforms.
Ghost to Substack
Substack imports Ghost posts from your site URL and members from Ghost's CSV export. Paid members move by connecting the Ghost Stripe account to Substack, which Substack documents as a one-click transfer.
Our migration guide covers warm-up, redirects and reader communication.
Choose Substack or Ghost
Choose Substack if
- You want zero setup and to focus purely on writing
- Discovery through the Substack network matters
- You are testing whether a paid newsletter works
- You do not need an API or custom design
Choose Ghost if
- You want your own brand, site and design
- A revenue share would cost you meaningful money
- You want APIs for automation and custom tools
- You have someone to own the setup, or will pay for hosting
A worked example
This publisher is fictional. It shows how the questions above play out, not a real result.
A historian writes a weekly paid essay on maritime history. She started on Substack and now has a steady paid base. Most new readers arrive through Substack recommendations and Notes. She wants a proper archive site and is tired of giving up a share of revenue.
Run the questions. Her revenue is subscriptions. Her growth depends on the network. She has no developer and no interest in servers.
Moving to Ghost(Pro) would cut the revenue share and give her a real site. It would also cut her off from the channel that brings most new readers, so she would need a new one, such as search traffic to her archive.
The sensible move is to measure first. If network growth stays dominant, Substack's fee is the price of that channel. If her archive starts bringing readers from search, Ghost(Pro) on the Publisher plan becomes the stronger fit.
What most comparisons miss
Self-hosting is a real commitment
Self-hosted Ghost is free software, but someone has to own updates, backups, security and email delivery through Mailgun. Ghost(Pro) removes that work for a fee.
The entry plan is not the paid plan
Ghost(Pro) Starter does not include paid subscriptions, custom themes or custom integrations. Compare Substack with the Ghost plan you would actually use.
The network effect is hard to replace
Some Substack writers get a large share of new readers from the network. Before leaving, find out where your growth actually comes from.
Ownership pays off with sponsors
A site and newsletter you control make it easier to offer clean sponsor placements, reporting and media kits.
How we help
We build custom themes, Admin API automations and sponsor systems on Ghost, and the tools that run alongside Substack. See our Ghost work, or read how to choose a newsletter platform for the wider field.
Weighing a move? Start with a process audit and get an honest recommendation, even if it is to stay put.
Platforms change their features and pricing often. Facts here were checked against each platform's help center and documentation in October 2026. Check each platform's current plans before you decide.