- Choose Kit if you are a creator selling digital products with automations.
- Choose Mailchimp if you run a store or service business and want broad marketing features.
- Kit bills on confirmed subscribers. Mailchimp bills on contacts, and unsubscribed contacts count until you archive them.
- Kit includes commerce with a per-sale fee and creator sponsorships. Mailchimp connects to your store instead.
- Both have mature APIs. Neither is built around editorial publishing.
At a glance
| Topic | ||
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Creators, educators and writers selling digital products | Small businesses, stores and service companies |
| How you pay | Plans by subscriber count, with a free tier; a per-sale Commerce fee that includes card processing | Plans by contact count and features, with a free tier and monthly send limits |
| Who counts toward the bill | Confirmed subscribers | Subscribed, unsubscribed and non-subscribed contacts, counted per audience |
| List structure | One list per account, organized with tags and segments | One or more audiences, organized with tags, groups and segments |
| Automations | Visual automations, sequences and tags | Marketing automation flows, with step limits by plan |
| Commerce | Digital products, paid newsletters and newsletter sponsorships built in | Integrations with stores and ecommerce tools, such as Shopify |
| Growth network | Creator Network recommendations, including paid recommendations | No creator recommendation network |
| Design | Clean, text-forward emails and landing pages | Rich template library and builder |
| Sending domain | Verified sending domain with SPF, DKIM and DMARC | Domain authentication with DKIM and DMARC |
| Team seats | One on free, more on paid plans, unlimited on Pro | One on free, more on each paid tier, unlimited on Premium |
| API | Full API on every plan, including free | Mature Marketing API, plus Transactional on higher plans |
The real difference
Kit thinks in subscribers, tags and products. Mailchimp thinks in audiences, campaigns and customers. Pick the one whose mental model matches how your business works.
Kit assumes the person on your list might buy something from you directly. Mailchimp assumes they buy from your store, and email is how you bring them back.
Who each one suits
By business model
A creator selling courses, templates or a paid newsletter fits Kit. Checkout, delivery and the follow-up sequence all live in one tool.
A shop or service business fits Mailchimp. It connects to stores such as Shopify and uses purchase and browsing data to trigger emails.
A publisher whose newsletter is the product fits neither perfectly. Both are marketing tools first. Newsletter-first platforms like Beehiiv or Ghost deserve a look, and our platform guide walks through them.
By stage
Both have free plans. Kit's covers a list of up to 10,000 subscribers, without visual automations or sequences. Mailchimp's free plan is aimed at very small lists, with one audience, one seat and a monthly send cap.
As you grow, the billing models diverge. That matters more than any feature.
How each one makes money from you
Kit sells monthly or annual plans priced by subscriber tier. Its help center says it bills on confirmed subscribers and moves you up a tier automatically when you pass the limit. Moving down is your call.
Kit Commerce has no monthly fee and is on every plan. You pay a fee on each sale, with card processing included. Kit also keeps a share of Newsletter Sponsorship and Paid Recommendation earnings.
Mailchimp sells Free, Essentials, Standard and Premium plans priced by contact count. Each plan has a monthly send limit set as a multiple of your contact limit. Go over your contact limit mid-cycle and sending continues, with an extra charge on your bill.
The key difference is who counts. Mailchimp includes subscribed, unsubscribed and non-subscribed contacts. Archived, cleaned and deleted contacts do not count. Audiences do not share contacts, so one person in two audiences counts twice.
Model both on your real list. A list with many past unsubscribes or several overlapping audiences can cost more on Mailchimp than its headline size suggests.
Automations
Kit's visual automations combine entry points, tags, conditions and sequences in one canvas. Sequences can be limited to certain days of the week. You can share an automation as a template, with its tags, sequences and forms, to another Kit account.
Mailchimp now calls its automations marketing automation flows, previously Customer Journeys. Its help center lists up to 4 steps on Essentials and up to 200 on Standard and above, with up to 3 triggers per flow on Standard or higher.
For a creator funnel, Kit's model is easier to reason about. For store-driven flows, such as abandoned carts and post-purchase emails, Mailchimp's store integrations do the heavy lifting.
Growth tools
Kit has a growth network built in. In the Creator Network you can recommend up to 20 creators, and up to five appear on your forms and landing pages. Paid Recommendations let you earn from recommending, and Kit lists them on its paid plans. A referral system runs through SparkLoop on the Pro plan.
Mailchimp's growth tools are signup forms, landing pages and a website builder. We found no equivalent of a creator recommendation network. Growth there comes from your own site, store and ads.
Monetization
Kit sells digital products and paid newsletters with discounts and pay-what-you-want pricing. Newsletter Sponsorships pay per unique verified click, and only paid plan users can express interest. Kit Ads adds programmatic ads once Kit approves your account.
Mailchimp does not sell on your behalf. You sell through your store or website, and Mailchimp ties emails to those orders through integrations.
Neither platform runs direct-sold sponsorships for you. Outreach, contracts and reporting sit outside both.
Ownership and data portability
Kit exports subscribers as a CSV with first name, email, signup date, status, tags, location, attribution data and custom fields.
Mailchimp's full account export is broader. It includes campaigns with their HTML, audiences split into subscribed, unsubscribed, non-subscribed and cleaned files, templates, and reports that can include open and click data for individual contacts.
Kit Commerce runs on a separate Kit-managed Stripe account, created even if you already have Stripe. Mailchimp leaves payments with your store. That affects what moves with you if you leave.
API and integrations
Kit's v4 API covers subscribers, tags, sequences, broadcasts, forms, custom fields, segments, purchases and webhooks, with API keys or OAuth. Kit says API keys are not restricted by plan, so the free plan can use the API too.
Mailchimp's Marketing API covers audiences and contacts, campaigns, templates, reports, ecommerce store data, account exports and webhooks, with batch operations. Users with Manager permissions or higher can create API keys. Mailchimp Transactional, a separate delivery API for one-to-one email, is available on Standard and Premium plans.
Both connect to most tools a small business uses. Check the exact endpoints you need on the plan you will buy.
Design and site control
Kit's emails lean plain and personal by default, with a visual template editor when you want more. Landing pages and a newsletter site can run on your own domain.
Mailchimp has a larger template library and a drag-and-drop builder suited to product-heavy emails. Its website builder includes landing pages on the free plan, and custom domains on paid plans.
Deliverability control
Kit asks you to send from a domain you own and walks you through a verified sending domain with SPF, DKIM and DMARC. The Pro plan adds deliverability reporting.
Mailchimp's domain authentication sets up DKIM through CNAME records and DMARC through a TXT record, with an automatic setup option. Mailchimp says it can improve delivery.
On both, authentication is your job and your reputation. Neither does list hygiene for you. Pruning inactive readers is a decision, and on Mailchimp it also affects the bill.
Analytics
Kit reports on broadcasts, sequences and automations, plus attribution data on where subscribers came from. Pro adds engagement analytics, subscriber engagement scoring and Subscriber Signals.
Mailchimp reports on campaigns and, with a store connected, purchases. Standard and Premium add predictive segmentation and multivariate testing.
Teams and multiple titles
Kit's pricing page lists one user on the free plan, two on Creator and unlimited on Pro. Kit keeps a single list per account and recommends separate accounts for businesses with distinct audiences.
Mailchimp sets both audiences and seats by plan, from one of each on Free to unlimited on Premium. Standard and Premium add more role-based access controls. Mailchimp recommends one main audience organized with tags, groups or segments, rather than many audiences.
If you run several newsletters, both platforms push you toward one list with tags. That is fine until readers want to manage each title separately. Test the unsubscribe flow before you commit.
Moving between them
From Mailchimp to Kit
- Export from Mailchimp. Import the subscribed file and keep the unsubscribed and cleaned files as suppressions.
- Map audiences, groups and tags to Kit tags. Kit has one list, so several Mailchimp audiences become one list with tags.
- Recreate forms, landing pages, templates and automations. Kit's own migration guide lists each as a rebuild.
- Pause automations before importing. Adding imported subscribers to tags or forms can trigger them.
- Kit's pricing page lists free migrations on paid plans. Check the current terms.
From Kit to Mailchimp
- Export subscribers from Kit with their tags and custom fields.
- Import into one Mailchimp audience. Mailchimp lets you apply tags and set each contact's marketing status during import.
- Unsubscribed contacts you import count toward your bill. Archive them, or keep suppressions outside Mailchimp.
- Rebuild sequences as flows, within your plan's step limits.
- Products sold through Kit Commerce need a new home, since Mailchimp does not sell for you.
In both directions, set up the new sending domain before the first send and warm up from your most engaged readers. Our migration guide covers each step, and platform migrations shows how we run them.
Choose Kit if
- You sell courses, downloads or paid newsletters
- You want simple, personal-looking emails
- Sequences drive your revenue
- You want a creator recommendation network
- Your list carries a lot of past unsubscribes
Choose Mailchimp if
- You run a store or service business
- You want a large template library
- You rely on its integration ecosystem
- Purchase data should trigger your emails
- Your team already knows it well
A worked example
This business is fictional. The example shows how the questions play out, not real results.
A design studio sends a weekly newsletter. It sells a template pack and runs a small online shop for prints. Its Mailchimp account has grown three audiences over the years, and many readers sit in more than one.
On Mailchimp, the shop integration already ties prints to emails. But the overlapping audiences and years of unsubscribes inflate the contact count. Merging into one audience with tags, then archiving old unsubscribes, fixes much of that without moving.
On Kit, the template pack sells natively and a sequence follows up with buyers. The print shop would still need its own store and a sync.
The deciding question is which product grows. If prints lead, cleaning up Mailchimp is the smaller job. If digital products lead, Kit fits the business better.
What most comparisons miss
Tags versus audiences
Kit uses one list with tags. Mailchimp accounts often have several audiences. Moving between them means rethinking structure, not just exporting.
Unsubscribes are not free on Mailchimp
Unsubscribed contacts count toward Mailchimp's bill until you archive them. Kit bills on confirmed subscribers. On an old list, that gap can be larger than the plan difference.
Send limits matter for daily newsletters
Mailchimp caps monthly sends as a multiple of your contact limit. A daily or multi-weekly newsletter should check that cap before it checks features.
Neither is a newsletter-first publisher tool
If the newsletter itself is your product, compare both with newsletter-first platforms like Beehiiv or Ghost.
Count the fees at your real volume
Model plan costs and transaction fees at next year's list size and sales.
How we help
We clean up tags and audiences, build sponsor operations and reader data sync, and plan moves in either direction. See our Kit and Mailchimp pages, or start with a process audit.
Platforms change their features and pricing often. Check each platform's current plans before you decide.