The short answer
  • Mailchimp is general email marketing software. Beehiiv is a newsletter publishing platform. They solve different problems.
  • If the newsletter is the product and earns from ads, sponsors or paid subscriptions, Beehiiv has more of that built in.
  • If email supports a store, a services firm or a wider marketing team, Mailchimp's journeys, segmentation and integrations may fit better.
  • Both sell plans that grow with your list. Mailchimp also counts unsubscribed and non-subscribed contacts, and counts a reader once per audience.
  • Mailchimp has no built-in paid subscriptions or ad network.

At a glance

Topic
Best forNewsletters as a businessEmail marketing for businesses that sell something else
How you payPlans by subscriber count and features; no cut of paid subscription or digital product revenuePlans by contact count and features; unsubscribed and non-subscribed contacts count
Growth toolsReferral program, free and paid recommendationsSignup forms, a website builder and a wide integration catalog
MonetizationAd network, paid subscriptions, digital products and sponsorshipsNo built-in paid subscriptions or ad network
AutomationsNewsletter automations on paid plansMature customer journeys and segmentation; journey depth depends on plan
PublishingNewsletter website and archive on every planCampaign archive and a basic website builder; no newsletter publishing site with paywalls or memberships
APIAPI for posts, subscribers and automations; creating posts needs a higher-tier plan and webhooks need a paid planMature Marketing API and webhooks; what you can do depends on plan
Data exportQuick or full subscriber export, plus a post content exportAudience export split by contact status; campaign reports export separately
Teams and titlesSeats and publications per workspace scale with planSeats and audiences scale with plan; duplicates across audiences are billed

Two different jobs

Mailchimp is built for businesses that market by email. A store, a clinic, a software company. The email serves something else.

Beehiiv is built for publishers whose email is the thing. The issue is the product, and the audience is the business.

That one difference explains most of the table above. It also means the right answer depends less on features than on how you make money.

Who each suits

By business model

Sponsorship-led. Either platform can carry a direct-sold sponsor slot. It is just a block in the issue. Beehiiv adds an ad network that can fill unsold inventory with advertiser offers. Neither runs the booking, contracts and invoicing for the deals you sell yourself.

Paid subscriptions. Beehiiv has paid tiers, a paywall and a website built in. Mailchimp has none of these natively. You would add a membership or paywall tool and sync paying readers into Mailchimp with tags.

Commerce and services. If email exists to sell products or book clients, Mailchimp's journeys, segmentation and integrations are the point. Beehiiv's publishing tools matter less here.

B2B lead generation. Both store custom fields and both have APIs. What decides it is whether you can capture job title and company, then sync them to your CRM on the plan you can afford.

By stage

Starting out, both offer a free plan with tight limits. Pick the one that matches where the business is headed, not the one you already have a login for.

Growing, the gap widens. Beehiiv's growth and revenue tools start to earn their keep. Mailchimp's costs climb with every contact on file, including people who no longer receive email.

Established, the questions shift to seats, multiple titles and data. Both scale those by plan, in different ways. More on that below.

How each makes money from you

Both sell plan tiers that grow with your list and unlock features as you move up. Neither model is a revenue share on subscriptions.

Beehiiv says it takes nothing from your paid subscription or digital product revenue. Card processing still costs something. Plans are banded by subscriber count.

Mailchimp counts contacts, and the definition matters. Subscribed, unsubscribed and non-subscribed contacts all count. Archived, cleaned and deleted contacts do not. Contacts are counted across every audience, so one reader in two audiences counts twice.

There are smaller lines too. Beehiiv keeps a fee on paid recommendations, built into the marketplace price. Mailchimp Transactional, its delivery API for automated messages, is a paid add-on on higher plans.

Check the current plan pages before you model costs. Both change their tiers often.

Growth tools

Beehiiv's growth tools are newsletter-specific. A referral program rewards readers for sharing. The Recommendations Network lets publications recommend each other for free, or pay per verified subscriber another publication sends.

Mailchimp's growth tools are general marketing tools. Signup forms, a website builder and a large catalog of integrations. There is no network of other newsletters to grow through.

If most of your growth comes from paid ads or partnerships you run yourself, this gap matters less. The tooling that tracks where each reader came from usually lives outside both.

Monetization

On Beehiiv, the ad network shows a small catalog of advertiser offers, paid per click or per impression. You claim an offer and publish it within a set window. Paid subscriptions and the ad network come with paid plans.

On Mailchimp, monetization is yours to assemble. A sponsor slot is a content block. A paid tier means a third-party paywall that tags paying readers. Reporting to sponsors comes from campaign reports.

For direct-sold sponsorships, the platform matters less than people expect on either side. Outreach, booking, approvals and reporting happen around the send, not in the editor.

Ownership and data portability

Mailchimp's audience export can arrive as a ZIP with separate CSV files for subscribed, unsubscribed, non-subscribed and cleaned contacts. It includes tags, opt-in time and IP, confirmation time and a member rating.

It does not include open and click data. Campaign reports export separately. If engagement history matters to you, pull it before you leave.

Beehiiv offers a quick or a full subscriber export from Settings, Export Data. The full export adds custom fields and statistics. Download links expire after 24 hours. Post content exports as a CSV on every plan.

Payments are the other half of ownership. Beehiiv paid subscriptions run through a Stripe account connected to Beehiiv, and Ghost's migration docs note that account cannot be connected to another platform. Paying readers do not move as easily as free ones.

API and integrations

Mailchimp's Marketing API is long-standing and widely supported, with webhooks for near real-time audience changes. Mailchimp notes that what you can do depends on your plan, and it limits simultaneous connections.

Beehiiv's API covers subscriptions, posts and automations. Creating posts through the API requires a higher-tier plan, and webhooks need a paid plan. Beehiiv's own pages have named different tiers for post creation, so confirm on the plan page before you build on it.

That gating is the detail that bites. A drafting pipeline or sponsor workflow that writes into the platform needs those endpoints on the plan you will actually buy.

Design and site control

Mailchimp has a drag-and-drop builder and allows custom-coded templates from its Standard plan. Its website builder suits a business site. There is no newsletter site with paywalls or memberships.

Beehiiv includes a newsletter website on every plan, with post templates and a public archive. Removing Beehiiv branding requires a higher plan.

Templates are where years of Mailchimp work tend to get stuck. Beehiiv's Mailchimp guide suggests building a new template first, because imported posts can only be restyled one by one.

Deliverability control

Both platforms run the sending infrastructure for you. Both let you authenticate your own domain with DNS records, and both offer a guided setup through Entri or a manual one.

That matters more every year. Gmail and Yahoo require custom authentication and a published DMARC record from senders who send more than 5,000 emails in a day.

Beehiiv lists dedicated IPs on its Enterprise plan. For most publishers, list hygiene does more for inbox placement than any IP setting. Our deliverability checklist covers the setup.

Analytics

Mailchimp's reporting is built around campaigns. A/B testing comes on Essentials and multivariate testing on Standard.

Beehiiv reports on posts and subscribers, with advanced analytics on paid plans. Neither ties a reader to sponsor revenue or CRM outcomes without work outside the platform.

Teams and multiple titles

Seats scale by plan on both. Mailchimp also limits the number of audiences by plan, with unlimited audiences on Premium. Since billing counts contacts per audience, several titles in several audiences can mean paying for the same reader more than once.

Beehiiv hosts multiple publications in one workspace, with the number allowed set by plan. Check how subscribers who read several of your titles are counted before you commit.

Moving between them

Mailchimp to Beehiiv

Subscribers move by CSV. You map tags and fields to Beehiiv, create custom fields for anything unmapped and confirm everyone opted in.

By default, Beehiiv sets each imported subscriber's subscription date to the import date. Keeping original dates needs help from its support team.

Content can come too. Beehiiv's content importer connects to Mailchimp and pulls campaigns, but only those built in Mailchimp's New Email Builder, launched in 2022. Older campaigns need recreating by hand.

Automations, signup forms and templates do not move. Plan to rebuild them.

Beehiiv to Mailchimp

The full subscriber export brings custom fields with it, and posts export as a CSV. Free subscribers move cleanly.

Paid subscriptions have no native home in Mailchimp, so they need a separate membership tool. Referral rewards, recommendations and the newsletter website stay behind. The archive needs a new home and redirects, or old links break.

Either way, warm up the new sender with your most engaged readers first. Our migration guide walks through each step, and our platform migrations page covers how we run them.

Choose Beehiiv if

  • Your newsletter is the product
  • You want referrals, an ad network and paid subscriptions in one place
  • You want a newsletter website, archive and paywall
  • You can live with API features gated by plan

Choose Mailchimp if

  • Email supports a store or services business
  • Your team relies on Mailchimp journeys and segments
  • You need its wide integration catalog
  • You keep one clean audience, so contact billing stays predictable

A worked example

This publisher is fictional. It shows how the questions above play out, not a real result.

A small team runs a weekly regional food newsletter. It started years ago as a cookware shop's mailing list on Mailchimp. There are now three audiences: newsletter readers, shop customers and cooking class attendees. Many people sit in two of them.

The team wants to launch a paid tier and sell sponsor slots to local producers.

Run the framework. The newsletter is becoming the product, which points toward Beehiiv's paid tiers and ad tools. But the shop still needs order-triggered emails, which is Mailchimp's home ground.

Two sensible paths. Move the newsletter to Beehiiv and keep the shop's flows on a cleaned, single Mailchimp audience. Or stay on Mailchimp, consolidate the audiences and add a paywall tool. The deciding question is which business they expect to be bigger in two years.

What most comparisons miss

Check how contacts are counted

Mailchimp counts unsubscribed and non-subscribed contacts toward your plan, not just active subscribers. Clean your audience before comparing costs.

Duplicate audiences inflate costs

Many Mailchimp accounts have the same people in several audiences. Consolidate before you compare or migrate.

Merging audiences erases history

Mailchimp's own guide warns that combining audiences does not carry over opens, clicks, member rating, opt-in timestamps, signup source or GDPR permissions, and cannot be undone. Export every audience first.

Your consent records are in the export

Opt-in time and IP sit in Mailchimp's contact export. Map them to custom fields on the new platform, so you can show when and how each reader signed up.

Old campaigns may not import

Campaigns from Mailchimp's older builder will not come through Beehiiv's importer. If your archive matters for search, budget time to recreate the issues that bring in readers.

Templates are the hidden migration cost

Years of Mailchimp templates rarely move cleanly. Plan to rebuild them as modular newsletter templates.

How we help

We work on both platforms: cleaning up Mailchimp audiences, building tools on the Beehiiv API and planning moves in either direction. One B2B trade newsletter we worked with ran on Beehiiv, then moved to its own sending infrastructure once reader data and custom workflows mattered more than built-in features. If you are weighing a move, start with a process audit and an honest recommendation.

Platforms change their features and pricing often. Check each platform's current plans before you decide.