- Beehiiv: for newsletters that want growth tools, an ad network and paid subscriptions in one place.
- Ghost: for ownership, memberships and a full site, hosted or self-hosted.
- Kit: for creators selling products and running automation-heavy funnels.
- Klaviyo: for publishers whose newsletter drives commerce.
- A custom stack: for full control of templates, data and sending.
- Staying put: often right when email supports a store or services business.
Why newsletters leave Mailchimp
- Cost. Mailchimp counts subscribed, unsubscribed and non-subscribed contacts, across every audience. A reader in two audiences counts twice.
- No newsletter monetization. No built-in paid subscriptions, ad network or sponsor tools.
- No newsletter publishing site. Its website builder is for business sites; an SEO archive, paywall and memberships need other tools.
- Campaign-first workflow. Built for marketing campaigns rather than recurring editorial issues.
- Plan-gated depth. Seats, audiences, journey steps and testing options all scale with the plan.
None of these is a flaw if email is a marketing channel. They become problems when the newsletter is the business.
When to stay put
Not every Mailchimp account should move. If email supports a store, a clinic or a services firm, Mailchimp's journeys, segmentation and integrations are doing the job they were built for.
Staying also makes sense when the real problem is the setup, not the platform. Three overlapping audiences, a pile of unsubscribed contacts and templates nobody can edit are fixable in place.
Mailchimp recommends keeping one audience and organizing it with tags and segments. Doing that, then archiving contacts you no longer email, often changes the cost picture more than a migration would.
A move puts your sender reputation and your team's routines at risk for weeks. Make sure the gain is bigger than that.
How to compare the alternatives
Start with how you make money, then check three things on each platform.
How it charges. Some platforms sell plans that grow with your list. Some take a fee on each sale. Some charge for hosting or sending and leave the rest to you.
What counts. Mailchimp bills unsubscribed contacts. Kit says unsubscribed subscribers do not count toward billing. Klaviyo bills on active profiles, the contacts who may receive marketing email. The same list can price very differently.
What comes across from Mailchimp. Every alternative below can take your subscribers. Very few take your content, templates or automations.
The alternatives at a glance
| Platform | Fits best | How it charges | From Mailchimp |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beehiiv | Newsletters growing with referrals, ads and paid tiers | Plans by subscriber count; no cut of paid subscription revenue | CSV subscriber import, plus a content importer for newer campaigns |
| Ghost | Publishers who want their own site, memberships and ownership | Managed hosting plans by members, or self-host the open-source software | Built-in members migrator; no content import |
| Kit | Creators selling digital products and running sequences | Plans by subscriber count, plus a per-sale fee on Commerce | Importer via API key with merge fields and tags |
| Klaviyo | Newsletters that drive commerce | Plans by active profiles | Built-in integration syncs contacts and recent campaign data, not tags |
| Custom stack (for example Resend) | Publishers who want full control of data, templates and sending | Pay for sending, plus the software you build around it | Whatever you build: contacts, suppressions and archive by script |
The alternatives
Beehiiv
Best for newsletters that want referrals, recommendations, an ad network and paid subscriptions in one place.
Beehiiv sells plans by subscriber count and says it takes nothing from paid subscription or digital product revenue. Every plan includes a newsletter website. Paid subscriptions and the ad network come with paid plans.
From Mailchimp, subscribers come across by CSV with tags and custom fields mapped. Beehiiv's content importer connects to Mailchimp and brings in campaigns built with the New Email Builder, launched in 2022. Older campaigns need recreating by hand.
Watch the API tiers. Creating posts through the API requires a higher-tier plan, so check before you build automation on it. Paid subscribers sit in a Stripe account connected to Beehiiv, which matters if you ever leave.
Beehiiv vs Mailchimp, compared
Ghost
Best for publishers who want their own site, memberships and full ownership.
Ghost is open-source software. You can self-host it or pay for managed Ghost(Pro) hosting, priced by members. On Ghost(Pro) plans that support paid subscriptions, Ghost takes no transaction fee. Payment processor fees still apply. Ghost 6 added ActivityPub, so a publication can be followed from the open social web.
Ghost has a built-in Mailchimp migrator for members. Its docs say it is not currently possible to migrate Mailchimp content, so the archive needs another route.
Self-hosting has a catch for newsletters. Ghost's docs say bulk newsletter email requires a bulk mail API, and Mailgun is the only one supported.
Kit
Best for creators selling digital products with automations and sequences.
Kit sells plans by subscriber count, and unsubscribed subscribers do not count toward billing. Commerce sales carry a per-sale fee that includes card processing. Newsletter sponsorships come with paid plans, and paid recommendations carry a Kit fee.
Kit's Mailchimp importer connects with your Mailchimp API key. It brings merge fields across and turns lists, tags and interests into Kit tags. Templates, forms, sequences and automations do not come across.
Kit thinks in funnels more than issues. Check which plan includes the features you need.
Klaviyo
Best for publishers whose newsletter drives commerce and needs revenue attributed to each send.
Klaviyo prices by active profiles, the contacts who may receive marketing email. Suppressed profiles do not count.
Its built-in Mailchimp integration syncs contacts, including unsubscribes and cleaned contacts, and maps audiences to lists. It brings over receives, opens, clicks and member ratings, but only the last 90 days of campaign data, in a one-time historical sync.
It does not sync tags. Export them and import them as custom properties. Templates move by export and import, with Mailchimp merge tags swapped for Klaviyo's.
A custom stack (for example Resend)
Best for publishers who want full control of sending, templates, data and production.
Resend gives you broadcasts sent to segments, topics that let readers choose what they receive, a broadcast editor and queuing and throttling handled for you. It does not give you signup forms, an archive or a website. Someone has to build those.
From Mailchimp, everything moves by script: contacts, consent fields, suppressions and the archive. That is more work up front and no importer limits.
This is the route one B2B trade newsletter we worked with took, from Beehiiv rather than Mailchimp, once reader data and custom workflows mattered more than built-in features.
Newsletter infrastructure on Resend
A worked example
This publisher is fictional. It shows how the choice plays out, not a real result.
A city arts newsletter goes out twice a week. It has run on Mailchimp for years and has grown to two audiences: the newsletter, and a ticket-buyers list from a partner venue. Revenue is sponsorship from local venues, with a paid tier under discussion.
Start with the money. Sponsorship-led today, maybe paid tomorrow. That points to a newsletter platform, not a commerce tool, so Klaviyo drops out.
Beehiiv suits them if they want the paid tier and an ad network soon. Ghost suits them if they want the archive on their own site and no transaction fees on paid members, and can handle more setup. Staying on Mailchimp suits them if the ticket list matters more than the paid tier, provided they consolidate the two audiences.
Whichever way they go, the first job is the same: export both audiences, deduplicate outside Mailchimp and keep the unsubscribed file as a suppression list.
Migration checklist for leaving Mailchimp
- Export every audience before changing anything. The export can arrive as a ZIP with separate files for subscribed, unsubscribed, non-subscribed and cleaned contacts.
- Export campaign reports too. Contact exports do not include open and click data.
- Deduplicate in the export, not by merging audiences in Mailchimp. Merging drops engagement, opt-in timestamps and GDPR permissions, permanently.
- Carry the unsubscribed and cleaned files across as suppressions.
- Keep consent fields such as opt-in time and IP as custom fields on the new platform.
- Find out which campaigns used the older email builder if you plan to import content.
- Swap Mailchimp merge tags in templates for the new platform's syntax.
- Rebuild signup forms, welcome sequences and journeys, and test them before cutover.
- Authenticate your sending domain on the new platform before the first send.
- Warm up with your most engaged readers first.
- Replace embedded Mailchimp forms on your site, partner sites and social profiles.
- Keep the Mailchimp account until the new platform has run cleanly for several sends.
Our migration guide covers each step in detail.
What most comparisons miss
Clean before you compare
Removing duplicates and inactive contacts can change the cost comparison dramatically, and it improves deliverability wherever you land.
Do not merge audiences on the way out
Mailchimp's combine process is permanent and drops opens, clicks, member rating, opt-in timestamps, signup source and GDPR permissions. Merge in a spreadsheet or a script instead.
Keep consent records
Bring across when and how each person subscribed, not just their email address. Mailchimp's export includes opt-in and confirmation time and IP.
Importers bring contacts, not systems
Every importer above moves subscribers. Forms, journeys and templates almost always need rebuilding. Budget for that, not just the import.
History has a cutoff
Klaviyo's integration pulls 90 days of campaign data. Beehiiv sets subscription dates to the import date by default. If engagement history drives your segments, export it yourself first.
Test the exit from your next platform
Leaving Mailchimp is a good moment to check how you would leave the next one. Run a full subscriber export in the first week and see what it contains.
Beehiiv's full export adds custom fields and statistics, and its download links expire after 24 hours. Paid subscribers there sit in a Beehiiv-connected Stripe account. Know which of your fields would survive a second move.
The archive is a search asset
Years of Mailchimp campaign pages may bring in readers from search. If no importer takes them, decide which issues are worth recreating on your own domain, where you control the links.
Not every Mailchimp user should move
If email supports a store or services business, optimizing your Mailchimp setup may beat a migration.
How we help
We clean up Mailchimp accounts that should stay, and plan moves for the ones that should not. That covers audience consolidation, template rebuilds, automations and cutover with deliverability protected. See how we run platform migrations, or read our guide to choosing a newsletter platform. When you are ready, start with a process audit.
Platforms change their features and pricing often. Check each platform's current plans before you decide.